Men's National Honors
 Shane Knoll |
 Marshall Dill |
 Andy Lixey |
 Brad Fields |
 Herb Washington |
 Anthony Hamm |
All-Americans
Indoor
| 2024 | Heath Baldwin | Heptathlon |
| 2023 | Heath Baldwin | Heptathlon |
| Trevor Stephenson | Pole Vault | |
| 2022 | Morgan Beadlescomb | Mile |
| Morgan Beadlescomb (Second Team) | 3,000 meters | |
| Trevor Stephenson (Second Team) | Pole Vault | |
| 2021 | Morgan Beadlescomb | 5,000 meters |
| 2020 | Morgan Beadlescomb | 5,000 meters |
| 2019 | Nick Guerrant | Heptathlon |
| 2018 | Tim Ehrhardt (Second Team) | Pole Vault |
| Nick Guerrant (Second Team) | Heptathlon | |
| 2017 | Tim Ehrhardt | Pole Vault |
| 2016 | Connor Kostrzewa (Second Team) | Weight Throw |
| Vinny Gjokaj (Second Team) | Weight Throw | |
| 2015 | Tim Ehrhardt | Heptathlon |
| Antonio James (Second Team) | Weight Throw | |
| 2014 | Antonio James | Weight Throw |
| Antonio James | Shot Put (Second Team) | |
| Kurt Schneider (Second Team) | Heptathlon | |
| Caleb Rhynard (Second Team) | 3,000-meter | |
| 2013 | Antonio James | Weight Throw |
| Lonnie Pugh (Honorable Mention) | Weight Throw | |
| 2012 | Lonnie Pugh | Weight Throw |
| Zack Hill | Shot Put | |
| Jay Gillespie (Second Team) | Weight Throw | |
| 2011 | Lonnie Pugh | Weight Throw |
| Zack Hill (Second Team) | Shot Put | |
| 2010 | Kyron Foster | Triple Jump |
| 2009 | Shane Knoll | Mile |
| 2006 | Brad Gebauer | Pole Vault |
| 2002 | Paul Terek | Decathlon |
| Steve Sherer | 3,000 meters | |
| 2001 | Paul Terek | Pole Vault |
| Steve Manz | Shot Put | |
| Andy Lixey | 800 meters | |
| 1999 | Jim Jurcevich | 5,000 meters |
| Steve Schell | 5,000 meters | |
| Kyle Baker | 3,000 meters | |
| 1998 | Jim Jurcevich | 5,000 meters |
| 1997 | Kyle Baker | 3,000 meters |
| 1996 | Brad Fields | 200 meters |
| 1995 | Brad Fields | 200 meters |
| 1994 | Brad Fields | 200 meters |
| 1991 | Chris Brown | 4x800-meter Relay |
| Rick Gledhill | 4x800-meter Relay | |
| Todd Koning | 4x800-meter Relay | |
| Chris Rugh | 4x800-meter Relay | |
| 1983 | Eliot Tabron | 440 yards |
| Sanders | 600 meters | |
| Marcus Sanders | 4x400-meter Relay | |
| Kelvin Scott | 4x400-meter Relay | |
| Eliot Tabron | 4x400-meter Relay | |
| Corky Wilkins | 4x400-meter Relay | |
| 1978 | Dennis Lewis | High Jump |
| 1977 | Randy Smith | 60 yards |
| 1974 | Bob Cassleman | 600 yards |
| 1973 | Marshall Dill | 60 yards |
| Bob Cassleman | 600 yard | |
| 1972 | Ken Popejoy | Mile |
| Herb Washington | 60 yards | |
| Bob Cassleman | 600 yards | |
| Alwin Henderson | Mile Relay | |
| Marshall Dill | Mile Relay | |
| Mike Murphy | Mile Relay | |
| Bob Cassleman | Mile Relay | |
| 1970 | John Mock | 880 yards |
| Herb Washington | 60 yards | |
| Bill Wehrwein | 600 yards | |
| 1968 | Don Crawford | Mile Relay |
| Dick Stevens | Mile Relay | |
| Pat Wilson | Mile Relay | |
| Bill Wehrwein | Mile Relay | |
| Roland Carter | Pole Vault | |
| 1969 | Bill Wehrwein | 600 yards |
| Herb Washington | 60 yards | |
| 1950 | William Mack | Mile |
Outdoor
| 2025 | Andrew Nolan (Honorable Mention) | 3,000m Steeplechase |
| 2024 | Ryan Talbot (Second Team) | Decathlon |
| 2023 | Heath Baldwin | Decathlon |
| John Petruno (Second Team) | 1500m | |
| Trevor Stephenson (Second Team) | Pole Vault | |
| Ryan Talbot (Second Team) | Decathlon | |
| 2022 | Morgan Beadlescomb | 5,000m |
| John Petruno (Second Team) | 1500m | |
| Trevor Stephenson (Second Team) | Pole Vault | |
| Heath Baldwin (Second Team) | Decathlon | |
| Ryan Talbot (Honorable Mention) | Decathlon | |
| 2021 | Morgan Beadlescomb    | 5,000m |
| Trevor Stephenson (Second Team) | Pole Vault | |
| Wade Walder (Second Team) | Decathlon | |
| 2019 | Justin Kiprotich | 1500m |
| Jerimiah Evans (Second Team) | Discus | |
| Morgan Beadlescomb (Second Team) | 5,000 meters | |
| 2018 | Tim Ehrhardt | Decathlon |
| Justin Kiprotich | 1500m | |
| Nick Guerrant (Second Team) | Decathlon | |
| Max Benoit (Second Team) | 3,000m Steeplechase | |
| 2017 | Justine Kiprotich | 1500 meters |
| Tim Ehrhardt (Second Team) | Decathlon | |
| Noah Gary (Second Team) | Pole Vault | |
| 2015 | Antonio James | Discus |
| Tim Ehrhardt | Decathlon | |
| Vinny Gjokaj (Honorable Mention) | Hammer | |
| 2014 | Kurt Schneider (Second Team) | Decathlon |
| Antonio James (Honorable Mention) | Shot Put, Discus | |
| 2013 | Antonio James (Second Team) | Discus |
| Caleb Rhynard (Second Team) | 5,000 meters | |
| Lonnie Pugh (Honorable Mention) | Discus | |
| Keenan Michael(Honorable Mention) | 400-meter Hurdles | |
| 2012 | Lonnie Pugh (Second Team) | Discus |
| 2011 | Lonnie Pugh | Discus |
| Codi Mattix (Second Team) | Pole Vault | |
| Zack Hill (Second Team) | Shot Put | |
| 2003 | Steve Manz | Shot Put |
| 2002 | Paul Terek | Decathlon |
| 2001 | Paul Terek | Decathlon |
| 2000 | Steve Schell | 10,000 meters |
| 1999 | Jim Jurcevich | 10,000 meters |
| 1998 | Jim Jurcevich | 10,000 meters |
| 1997 | Kyle Baker | 5,000 meters |
| 1991 | Anthony Hamm | 10,000 meters |
| 1990 | Anthony Hamm | 10,000 meters |
| 1987 | Tim Simpson | 1,500 meters |
| 1983 | Paul Piwinski | High Jump |
| Marcus Sanders | Mile Relay | |
| Kelvin Scott | Mile Relay | |
| Eliot Tabron | Mile Relay | |
| Corky Wilkins | Mile Relay | |
| 1982 | Eliot Tabron | 400 meters |
| 1980 | Paul Piwinski | High Jump |
| 1979 | Keith Moore | 1,000 yards |
| 1973 | Marshall Dill | 220 yards |
| 1973 | Rob Cassleman | 440 hurdles |
| 1969 | Bill Wehrwein | 440 yards |
| 1967 | Bob Steele | 440-yard hurdles |
| 1966 | Bob Steele | 440-yard hurdles |
| 1965 | Daswell Campbell | 440-yard relay |
| Clint Jones | 440-yard relay | |
| Jim Summers | 440-yard relay | |
| Gene Washington | 440-yard relay | |
| 1956 | Henry Kennedy | 3,000-meter Steeplechase |
| Selwyn Jones | 5,000 meters | |
| Selwyn Jones | 10,000 meters | |
| 1951 | Bob Carey | Shot Put |
Great Lakes Men's Indoor Field Athlete of the Year
| 2024 | Heath Baldwin |
| 2023 | Trevor Stephenson |
Great Lakes Men's Indoor Track Athlete of the Year
| 2009 | Shane Knoll |
| 2022 | Morgan Beadlescomb |
Great Lakes Men's Outdoor Field Athlete of the Year
| 2024 | Heath Baldwin |
| 2018 | Tim Ehrhardt |
Great Lakes Assistant Coach of the Year
| 2023 | Ceith Creekmur (Outdoor) |